Rejection!
Your Membership Card
They rejected my ______!(fill in the blank). Said with a sigh, with a scream, or maybe a shrug, but almost always accompanied by expletives. The rejection notice has got to be the worst of the (several) agonies of writing.
So, I'll address the issue of rejections here. Whether or not you embrace it, rejection is the badge of honor of every working writer. You can't call yourself a true writer until you have earned a fair number of rejection slips.
A Historical Perspective
Once upon a time, before the Internet, even before personal computers, I wrote a lot of letters to editors, replete with article ideas so novel, so creatively brilliant, I imagined PR agencies bidding to manage my impending fame.
Starting a few weeks later, don't forget we're talking about postal delivery in those days, the rejection slips started to arrive. The dribble turned into stacks, the stacks into file drawers. And because I'm either a pack rat or irretrievably anal, I kept the missives. As you'll see I put them to good use. But, first, a diversion.
Segue to many years later, on the first few minutes of the opening class when I taught writing. I stood silently in front of the class and put on an overhead projector (high tech in those days) and placed a transparency of a query I sent to an editor, followed by his rejection slip. That was followed by 12 other queries and 12 other rejections for the same idea. That query process took me nearly a year. Then on the 13th query I received an acceptance (and eventually a publishing credit and a check). Now I showed the final slide. That 13th query was addressed to the same editor as I had started with!
The article went on to become the magazine's most commented article in years, as readers recollected the memories it raised for them.
The point is that rejection has to be taken for what it actually is. As an editor, even an Editor-In-Chief, at various times over the years, I've been in the same position of making a judgement on acceptance or rejection. The dirty secret is that those decisions are often made after a night of drinking or a fight with a spouse (even both, perish the thought). Maybe the editor already accepted a similar query because the topic is in the news. Perhaps the owner said that the budget is tight and we have to cut back a bit. My point here is that you never know the true reason for the rejection, assuming you've written a compelling, grammatically correct and no-spelling-errors query letter (more on that topic in future newsletters).
Decoration Motivation
If you're wondering what I did with all those rejection slips, I was perversely proud of them. I could brag that I had been rejected by some of the best magazines in the world (yes, the doc I was seeing at the time was a real psychiatrist. He had awards on his wall and no rejection slips).
I did what any modestly brain addled writer would do. I went to the hardware store, bought some wallpaper paste and a brush, and papered one entire wall of my study with those slips; sideways, straight, upside down, Reader's Digest, Fortune, New York Times, Omni, Forbes, Good Housekeeping... the list and the wallpaper went on and on.
As I began to rack up acceptances over the years (650+ published articles), the wall brought me lots of smiles.
Badge of Honor Authors
For those of you either starting out or experiencing a trove of rejections, the following might help. Here's a partial list of some famous authors and the dumb-ass editors and agents that rejected their books. The same holds true for non-book writers.
Agatha Christie
Her debut novel, Snow Upon the Desert: 6 rejection
Went on to write 75+ best selling books
J.K. Rowling
Harry Potter: 12 rejections
Rowling went on to sell 25 book titles and 600 million+ copies as of 2023
Stephen King
Carrie: 30 rejections
Best seller; movie
Frank Herbert
Dune: 23 rejections
Best seller; movies
Margaret Mitchell
Gone With he Wind: 39 rejections
Best seller; major movie
John Grisham
A Time to Kill: 28 rejections
Best seller
Shel Silverstein
The Giving Tree: rejected multiple times over four years of submissions
Best seller
Dr. Suess
Mulberry Street: 27 rejections
Best seller; television shows; and a long career
Madeline L’Engle
A Wrinkle in time: 26 rejections
Newberry Award winner
Yann Martel
Life of Pi: 5+ rejections
Won the Man Booker Prize
Stephanie Meyers
Twilight: rejected by 14 out of 15 literary agents (some of whom haven't yet committed suicide)
Best seller; major films
Audrey Niffenegger
The Time Traveler’s Wife: rejected by 25 literary agents
William Golding
Lord of the Flies: 21 rejections
Best seller; movie
Anne Frank
The Diary of a Young Girl: 15 rejections
Now, go write!

Discussion about this post